what's a mulatto?

The Brazilian identity-racial limbo, the production of black subjectivities, and the identity claiming.

Writing
Photography
Performing Arts
Audiovisual
Written by
Jota Ramos
in
English
Published on
Oct 18, 2022

Performance by Jota Ramos. Photo by Douglas Pingituro.

"todas da gente vaga, e baça, donde diz, quiere dezir, que la gente dessas partes es de color ni branca, ni negra, que em Portugal llamamos pardo, o amulatado, porque se llaman mulatos los hijos de negro y blanco, a los quales de essa mescla de padres que da esse color dudoso, o neutral entre los dos malistimo sin duia, porque hasta alli sea malo, el ser neu- tral, cosa aborrecible" [Bluteau, v. 5, 1720, pp. 628].

In Brazil, the sense of racial democracy deconstructs as we discuss the eugenicist policies introduced by governments that value white aesthetics. The discourse that the mulatto is the expression of Brazilianness breaks down, as the authorization for extra racial unions had the objective of "improving" the race. Kabengele Munanga debates the foundations of a Brazilian nationalist "identity" in which the so-called minorities - which, in fact, after an erased majority - cannot build mobilizing political identities. For the author, both in our past and present, the ideal of whitening and its atavisms is what materialized the mestizos, with the mulatto being a political-ideological and racial project of the elites. The mixed-blood subject is, first of all, the product of centuries of institutional rape of black and indigenous women - of the violation of the bodies of enslaved people or, as Abdias do Nascimento writes: "[to solve the threat of the 'black spot'] one of the resources used was the rape of the black woman by the whites of the dominant society, giving rise to the products of mixed blood: the mulatto, the pardo, the moreno, the pardavasco, the man-of-color, the fusco." Second of all, the miscegenation becomes the nexus that articulates non-racism since it is inscribed in the narrative of the nation as the "material proof" that racism does not exist, since mixed people cannot be racist. In this sense, miscegenation acts as an antidote to racism while functioning as a whitening strategy, serving the eugenicist purpose.

The brown person, since childhood, is referred to with euphemisms for "black" or "indigenous", such as "moreno", "moreninho", "mulato", "indiozinho", "marronzinho", "café com leite", and many others. They perceive themselves, all the time, as racialized but never explicitly as black or indigenous. So, when asked about "what they are", they might readily answer "brown", without understanding that brown is not a racial identity, brown is a color. The indefiniteness of brown constituted over this color/race a position of in-between-place. For Bhabha, "these 'in-between-places" provide the ground for elaborating strategies of subjectivation - singular or collective - that give rise to new signs of identity and innovative positions of collaboration and contestation. Brown marks the passage from one opposite to the other while blurring any notion of a border. For statistical purposes, brown is a color that results from the crossing of white and black races/ethnicities: it is the symbol of mestizaje. But its use suggests the need to go beyond this understanding. The very terms used in racializing these people are pejorative. Grada Kilomba, in an interview with Djamila Ribeiro, said: in Lisbon there is also this whole hierarchization of terms like 'mulatto' and 'mestiço'. And people use the term without knowing what it means. These terms are linked to hybrid animals, a reference to the black body as an animal. They are derogatory. If euphemisms deny the brown person their identity, it should also be denied as a form of identification since most of the terms that identify also sexualize and dehumanize mixed-race people.

Performance by Jota Ramos. Photos by Douglas Pingituro.

"The brown person, as they do not feel black, indigenous, or white, they also do not feel entitled to speak of racism from any perspective, giving rise to the silence of brown people. These subjects mistakenly perceive themselves as being on the margins of racism, sometimes denying its structuralism and preventing their experiences from composing the mass of antiracist criticism necessary to break the instruments of white oppression on blackness and indigenous communities".

Therefore, as a strategy of genocide, whitening has been transformed within the racial context. If before it happened through rape and institutional immigration policies, now it also denies its products their own identity. Exactly because of this, the brown person, as they do not feel black, indigenous, or white, they also do not feel entitled to speak of racism from any perspective, giving rise to the silence of brown people. Thus, these subjects mistakenly perceive themselves as being on the margins of racism, sometimes denying its structuralism and preventing their experiences from composing the mass of antiracist criticism necessary to break the instruments of white oppression on blackness and indigenous communities. As Fernandes and Souza point out, the fable of racial democracy conceals racial tensions and creates the illusion of inclusion, silencing voices that denounce real and symbolic violence, building, in many ways, both places of privilege and of exclusion and discrimination. The daily social stigmatizations and humiliations, explicit or implicit, subtle or veiled, often lead to the formation of a fragile black identity. The whitening ideal leads some black people to the paradox installed in their subjectivity - to desire everything that represents its negation, that is, whiteness.

For Abdias do Nascimento, the term is a simple metaphor identified by conscience and action: "mulatto" is the one who takes on the racist discourse and wants to approach whiteness, and "black" is a person who is aware of and committed to their people, their identity and their cultural heritage. Since Brazilian racism is structural to our society and brown people make up the majority of it, it is impossible to think about the dynamics of confronting systems of white oppression without discussing the brown condition. "What's a Mulatto" questions the origin of the mulatto's racial identity; the understanding of their situation of vulnerability; the understanding of the displacement from the device of mestizaje to the dispositive of blackness; the feeling of not belonging and consequently an ambiguous and fragmented identity; and the denunciation of a pejorative term that objectifies the light-skinned black body and exposes its etymological origin: an improper mixture that should not exist.

Performance by Jota Ramos. Photos by Douglas Pingituro.

References

BHABHA, H. K. (2007), O Local da Cultura, Belo Horizonte, Editora UFMG.
FERNANDES, Viviane B; SOUZA, Maria Cecília C.C. Identidade Negra entre exclusão e liberdade. Revista do Instituto de Estudos Brasileiros, São Paulo, n.63, (p. 103-120), abr. 2016.
MUNANGA, Kabengele. Nem Preto Nem Branco. Escravidão e relações raciais no Brasil e no EUA. Rio de Janeiro, Editorial Labor do Brasil, 1976.
NUNES, Zita Cristina. Race, Miscigenation, and the Construction of a National Identity: The Modernist Period in Brazil. Tese de Doutorado, University of California at Berkeley, 1994.
SCHWARCS, Lilia Moritz. O Espetáculo das Raças. Cientistas, Instituições e a Questão Racial no Brasil 1870-1930. São Paulo, Cia das Letras, 1995.
SILVA, Graziela M; LEÃO, Luciana T. S. O paradoxo da mistura: Identidades, desigualdades e percepção de discriminação entre brasileiros pardos. Revista brasileira de ciências sociais, São Paulo, v.27, n.80, p.117-255, out 2012.
SOUZA, Neusa S. Tornar-se negro: as vicissitudes da identidade do negro brasileiro em ascenção social. 1. ed. Rio de Janeiro: Edições Graal, 1983.

No items found.

Performance by Jota Ramos. Photos by Douglas Pingituro.